BI 110 Catherine Stinson and Jessica Thompson: Neuro-AI Explanation

July 06, 2021 • 01:25:02
BI 110 Catherine Stinson and Jessica Thompson: Neuro-AI Explanation
Brain Inspired
BI 110 Catherine Stinson and Jessica Thompson: Neuro-AI Explanation

Jul 06 2021 | 01:25:02

/

Show Notes

Catherine, Jess, and I use some of the ideas from their recent papers to discuss how different types of explanations in neuroscience and AI could be unified into explanations of intelligence, natural or artificial. Catherine has written about how models are related to the target system they are built to explain. She suggests both the model and the target system should be considered as instantiations of a specific kind of phenomenon, and explanation is a product of relating the model and the target system to that specific aspect they both share. Jess has suggested we shift our focus of explanation from objects – like a brain area or a deep learning model – to the shared class of phenomenon performed by those objects. Doing so may help bridge the gap between the different forms of explanation currently used in neuroscience and AI. We also discuss Henk de Regt’s conception of scientific understanding and its relation to explanation (they’re different!), and plenty more.

Timestamps:
0:00 – Intro
11:11 – Background and approaches
27:00 – Understanding distinct from explanation
36:00 – Explanations as programs (early explanation)
40:42 – Explaining classes of phenomena
52:05 – Constitutive (neuro) vs. etiological (AI) explanations
1:04:04 – Do nonphysical objects count for explanation?
1:10:51 – Advice for early philosopher/scientists

Other Episodes

Episode 0

October 30, 2023 • 01:13:54
Episode Cover

BI 177 Special: Bernstein Workshop Panel

Support the show to get full episodes and join the Discord community. I was recently invited to moderate a panel at the Annual Bernstein...

Listen

Episode 0

September 12, 2021 • 01:30:38
Episode Cover

BI 113 David Barack and John Krakauer: Two Views On Cognition

David and John discuss some of the concepts from their recent paper Two Views on the Cognitive Brain, in which they argue the recent...

Listen

Episode 0

March 28, 2020 • 01:28:25
Episode Cover

BI 064 Galit Shmueli: Explanation vs. Prediction

Galit and I discuss the independent roles of prediction and explanation in scientific models, their history and eventual separation in the philosophy of science,...

Listen